Not Hip to be Foursquare

by Scarlett on March 15, 2010 · View Comments

in Popped Culture

I have to admit, with a mixture of sheepishness and “meh”, that when it comes to personal technology and social networking, I tend to be a few years behind the curve. I didn’t jump on the Facebook or Twitter bandwagons until 2009; I don’t own a smartphone and I’ve never used picture mail or the camera on my feeble little LG; I rock a 5 year old beast of an iPod that goes through batteries like it’s going out of style … Hell, I don’t even have a laptop or netbook to speak of – the ultimate sin of someone who professes to <3 technology. Still, there are times when I feel a sort of pride in being a little old school - most often when I start hearing troubling accounts of the newest iPhone app or weird web phenomenon (see my post about Chatroulette) gone awry. Amongst the fascinating labyrinth of articles in my busy Google Reader this weekend, there were a number of tidbits surrounding Foursquare, a web and mobile phone app introduced last year that now boasts over 450,000 members.

What’s the point of Foursquare? Glad you asked! It allows members to “check in” when they visit a new location throughout their day – be it a movie theater, a gas station, their place of employment, you name it. Users can then earn points and unlock badges for visiting certain locations – which, for some particularly competitive and boastful folks, is all the fodder that was needed to make the service a huge success. The sad part is that the lure of gaining a shiny, pixel-based and meaningless badge has overshadowed common sense to such a degree that a new trend has emerged – and a frightening one at that. Forget cyber stalking … In 2010, it’s all about Foursquare stalking.

avatar i see you
I see you … and I’m watching you.”

Here’s how Foursquare works to enable stalkers. By utilizing the GPS inside your phone, every time you arrive at a new location, the app asks you if you’d like to check in – and then broadcasts your location to your Foursquare friends. This alone might not be particularly worrying – after all, many of us have expressed to friends that we were going to the movies or taking a vacation. But more and more Foursquare users are opting to broadcast their check-ins to other social networking streams – and unless you have tightly protected and privatized Twitter and Facebook accounts, this practice could definitely spell bad news bears. To give an example, a creepy first-person account was posted at TwiTip about the dangers of publicly notifying your social networking kin that you’re not at home. This fella was working at a coffee shop when someone called on the cafe’s business line asking to speak with him, posing as a “concerned neighbor”, and claiming that his apartment was being robbed. The whole thing turned out to be a prank – or perhaps a pointed wake-up call at how easily this checking in business could be exploited.

Last month, a few Dutch developers took a more “in your face” approach and launched PleaseRobMe.com, which caught the attention of many of the major internet and social networking blogs. Mashable wrote about the site, which aggregates live Foursquare check-ins that have been posted to public Twitter streams. It’s eye-opening stuff, seeing how ignorant people about broadcasting their locations. For example, by clicking on one of the most recent check-in listings and scanning through the last page of her Twitter account, I found her full name and picture, a list of places she regularly hangs out, and her place of employment. I’m willing to bet she’s also on Facebook, and with a little crafty maneuvering I could probably get her to accept a friend request – at which point there’s no telling all the information I could collect about her. It sketches me out just thinking about it – but this guy actually tested the theory, and the results were alarming.

All of this leads me to wondering … Why use Foursquare to begin with? I only had a vague notion of what it was before I read those articles, and even with my scant knowledge of it, I thought it sounded pointless. I guess some people like the idea that they could check in somewhere, and maybe some nearby friends would drop in for an impromptu meet-up. But so could your ex-lover. So could one of your parents. So could that creepy dude from your Comp-Sci lab who’s been secretly pining over you for months.

Am I’m just being paranoid? Is there something about the positive aspects or purpose of Foursquare that I’m missing? Maybe its popularity is just a product of the changing landscape of internet transparency. Back in January, Mark Zuckerberg (the founder of Facebook), was interviewed about the sweeping privacy policy changes that were put into effect in December, which rendered ALL previously private account information to be completely public and searchable. Many users hastily rushed to rectify this upheaval in their settings, but thousands (perhaps millions) of others have been ignorant of the changes. He offered a vague explanation, saying that people are so used to sharing their information online, it’s become a “social norm”. I don’t know – I still think that people can maintain some semblance of privacy online, and more importantly, they should. Being over-exposed on the interwebs can lead to troublesome situations – and I don’t mean “exposed” in the smexy, amateur pornography manner. (Where can I sign up for a service that informs me when my friends are nekkid? That would RAWK!)

Do any of you use Foursquare? I’d love to hear your thoughts! Oh, and as I was writing this post, I peeped into my Twitter and a pop-up box asked me to turn on geo-location for my account. Jeezy Creezy, where does it end? I think I’mma go hibernate for a while.

igloo hibernation
I wonder if they have Wi-Fi?
  • Needs_Moar_Desu

    Aww… its ok, Scarlett! I know what its like to be behind the times as well. I didn't first have a twitter account until Summer 09', nor did I have Facebook account until 2009 as well…. both are gone now, Facebook deleted my account for no reason, and I deleted my Twitter account (which I spent 7 months on) because it was addictive. Been Twitter free for nearly 2 months! Though I'm betting I'll rejoin this Summer. But anyway, my family didn't own a DVD player until 2005, and I didn't own MP3- or a game console- or a computer- until…. *GASP* 2007! So behind on the times! I still don't have an iPhone and all that other fancy junk… though I have a PS3 now :D. However, I still do not own a camera. I use the little disposable ones. Apparently this has been passed down from the generations, though…. my mom didn't own a color TV until after her first marriage… and that was in the late 80s!

    Anyway, about Foursquare- I had not heard of it before, but it reminded me of something. Did you know there are many twitter apps which allow you to track where a person is tweeting from, and if they're moving and such? Creepy stuff.

  • http://twitter.com/AdamZwakk Adam Zwakenberg

    I've never found this type of app interesting.. for the reasons you listed. :P

    I just don't see the point of tracking people to THAT extent or why you would want to.

  • bethanythemartian

    I know robbers check obituaries in papers to see when people are going to be at a funeral. While I try not to be too paranoid about my information on the internet (my first and last name and hometown are pretty much freely available and my name isn't common) I do think that foursquare is a breaking and entering waiting to happen.

  • Stephrosyne

    I definitely think you're far from being paranoid. As more and more people become comfortable using the Internet and exploring different websites, they're being lulled into a false sense of security that they can just post anything, even under their real name, and not have it affect their real life. There are people who are even offended when someone on the Internet keeps their identity secret – take the make-up gurus Elle and Blair on YouTube. They've had a ton of haters when it was discovered that their names weren't really Elle and Blair – but what do people expect? Blair is only 16 – she was 15 when she started on YouTube and claimed she was 18 at her parents' request when she decided to sign up – and Elle is living on her own. But instead of seeing it as protecting themselves by using fake names and not saying what states they lived in, people saw it as lying. I think it's absolutely ridiculous.

    As for sites like Foursquare, I think part of it is that it makes people feel important. Sites like Twitter and Foursquare almost have a celebrity gossip feel to it – people are reading what you're doing and where you're going, just like weekly tabloids which only exist to talk about who's been doing what and where they've been going. These days, you don't have to be a celebrity to have hundreds or even thousands of people wanting to know these kinds of things, you just have to know how to work social networking sites.

    And ironically enough, this is all coming from someone who has her Facebook and Twitter publicly available. :) Yay for hypocrisy!

  • http://www.2guys.info/ J.D.

    I find a little paranoia to be healthy. Foursquare, though, is too much. I give out too much info on Facebook as it stands, but my info and status updates are friends-only.

    As far as the badges go, they need something to grow their ePeen. That's all there is to it. Just like the 360's Gamerscore and PS3's Trophies.

  • http://twitter.com/kmag1up Krista Magliari

    people are just ignorant to how really exposed they are online. The think that they are this unknown and no one will ever want to look them up. There are really creepy people out in the interwebs that no one thinks they will ever meet. it's that whole “it could never happen to me” mental image and at the same time a small need to be known and exposed.

  • coeri

    Hurray for the Dutch developers!!!!! /Happy Dutchman

  • DerKork

    I'm glad I never heard of that service before – I'd never use it myself as I like to protect a bit of my identity from many people I don't know.

  • liqui

    Except for the coincidentially-meet-someone-you-know-thingy, I actually can't imagine a situation where this app would prove useful.
    That badge-system reminds me of the wow-achievement system, where people don't even realise they are doing tedious and boring things (like solving all the lowlevel quests), just so long as they get these points…so they stick to the game, and pay their 13$ a month.
    While in online games this trick seems to be used in order to make up for lacking content, in real life (at least I think so) companies could use it to analyze peoples habitsand behavior patterns and somehow use the data for marketing. (Not to think of all the creeps who can see where you're going anytime they want :x )

    Or maybe it's just me being far too paranoid.
    At least people still have the choice whether they want this or not, wouldn't sell my privacy for virtual stuff though.

    Greets

  • penisenvy

    I am less concerned about stalking and more annoyed by the idea that people really think anyone cares. It's like…great, you're at work. Oh, now you're at a restaurant? Thrilling! (Not.)

  • Renaissance_nerd

    I'm old school too Scarlett. I still have a shiver down my spine just giving out my real name online. I agree 100% people need to step back and realize what can easily be taken and used the wrong way. You just checked in that your at work? Great now it's time to call that “friend” with the white van to come “clean” your house and i won't be blamed for a damn thing. Oh and i'll be x amount of dollars richer too.

    never ever ever gonna see me on foursquare.

  • http://www.facebook.com/reptyle216 Brad Johnson

    If it's any consolation, you're more up on these things than I am, since I've never even heard of Foursquare till now. But I totally agree with what you're saying. Not only is it potentially dangerous, but what makes you think people give a damn that you went to Chipotle for lunch? My facebook updates are full of enough useless crap as it is.

  • http://blog.skitchstudio.com Michael "Skitch" Schiciano

    Nice write up, Scarlett! I looked at foursquare once, but I never really cared to utilize it because, honestly, it's just that one step too far about letting people know what I'm doing, where I am, what color shirt I'm wearing and the like. :P

    Granted, I'm aware of how much info people can find on people through the webz with a little tech and knowledge, I still find some of the social networking stuff to be fun….some of 'em, though, not all of it.

    I do has me a smartphone, if only because I like apps and other cool little gadgets to help with my music, gaming, and, um…gaming geekery (still waiting for a DnD 4th ed character manager and generator for Android/iPod touch…only found a manager so far), but that's part of the fun of the tech world, one can expose/utilize as much or as little as he/she chooses, in my view. :)

    As for exposing too much info…just wait til the day where people can hook up and tweet what they are dreaming while they're asleep..that'd leave to some funny updates from folks (especially if there are certain sexy-time dreams involved). ;)

  • adampad85

    That's got potential to be really, really creepy. It sounds like the old Boost Mobile campaign from a few years ago that bragged about being able to stalk your friends. That kind of tech's too easily abused in my book.

  • aaronodeneau

    as always a very poinant topic and one i fear will become the norm. that people will make themselves open and accessable at any and all times. but also it taps into the newer behavior of man to compete on unparalleed levels. if you ever get the chance check out the lyrics to revolting cocks song “viagra culture.” for it's time it's a rather prophetic song about the obsession to win and be the best at anything and everything. for me i could care less i'm a noob at online games where 12 year olds make up new words to desribe how badly i suck so i don't even try.

    but look at the current generation of games out there on ps3 and xbox 360. they now come with “trophies” or “acheivments” to unlock. in most cases these things are meaningless icons that save to your account. on occation they actualy tied to unlockables but that is rare and the quality of the things you get depends greatly on taste.

    but beyond that i can't imagine entriely what the appeal of foursquare is. i'm sorta in the middle i am aware of newer technologies but i don't rush to buy the newest things cause lately things are built to break. remember the atari 2600…a good lot of them work like they day they were made. games too. now if you get a hairline sctarch on the disc it can sometimes ruin the games ability to play and even then the game companies won't fix it,also the systems my god they break easier then the orginal robotech transforming toys (that i owned.). so i am not suprised at all the problems technology as a whole are creating…i am not saying it's a conspiracy i am just saying that cryslter could make an all metal bumper that never breaks they just aren't that stupid.

    people often do things without thinking. it's easy to feel that the internet is the one place you can turn to and put ourself out there without any thought of consequences or meeting anyone you post to. but now i guess the nets evolving to be become something like in gamer where we'll have something on our bodies that keeps us connected to the net at all times but also shows where we are. in someways like if you lost in the woods this would be an incredible way to always find people or if you were kidnapped but on the other hand there is a line that has to be drawn as to when and where we are located at.

    as i close this out i figure i'd say…for better or worse i put my location on twitter but to be honest i don't really use it all that much so my worries that people will know that i am at work on any given day and will come to my home where someone is always home isn't all that big for me. can i say it's a smart idea none the less. meh probably not in the best of ideas but i don't know i just didn't feel the harm at the time.

  • GonzoLink

    Jesus… this is why I stay away from social networking sites for the most part. I have a Facebook and even a Twitter, but I never really use them unless I need to contact a friend and I have no other options. I can certainly see the purpose and the appeal behind Foursquare, but I still feel like privacy should be be a more heavily valued and protected element on the internet. I just don't understand why people can't call each other up if they want to hang out and instead have to schedule an event on Facebook. Eh…
    BTW, Foursquare was an AWESOME game when I was younger. I haven't played it in years but it was always the one thing I stood in line on the playground at recess to be a part of. So cool…

  • SethTheXenocide

    Four Square would only be cool if it was oddly specific and I did it only at inappropriate places.

    “Seth has checked in to his bathroom!”

    “Seth has checked in to the gynecologist's office!”

    “Seth has checked in to the park bench next to the children's playground where perverts go to scope out the children!”

    And so on.

  • http://www.google.com/profiles/Neuronin Neuronin

    Stalkers and narcissists seem to be the market for this crap. Every time I see one of these new apps I think of this: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2006/6/19/

  • Alzrius

    One must appreciate the irony that right after this article, you come to the “Sharing is sexy!” message.

  • aaronodeneau

    oddly enough someone down here in texas was robbed after reporting that that were going to work on facebook. it was caught on camera though i didn't get to see the news story i had to take my son to school. freaky how profetic this all is.

  • EvilClaire

    I don't go in for internet social networking. Twitter? Could care less. Facebook? My mother lives on it. That's all i need is to tell me i don't need to go near it. The four square thing sounds horrible. I mean, i have had my fair share of creepy stalkerish guys. why do i need to broadcast to them? I'm glad you wrote this. Makes me glad i don't do it. oh, and have you heard of e-hibernate? wave of the future. :p

  • Poopoo

    Krista Magliari is a FURRY!

  • http://www.coffee-break-arcade.net coffee break arcade

    Do you like to play coffee break arcade games? If so, then you are like millions of others out there who really have a good time playing them. Today, though, it is not as easy to find such games as it was in the pasts. Perhaps that is because more people are playing their console sports like Xbox and Playstation or the surge of online sports that are free to operate.

blog comments powered by Disqus